| 2004 |
|
| Evan Carbotti '04 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Geoff Estilow '06 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Chris Hade '07 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Scott Liston '04 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Taylor Palmer '07 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Zak Putnam '04 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Josef Stave '05 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2005 |
|
| Geoff Estilow '06 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Taylor Jackson '06 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Taylor Palmer '07 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Josef Stave '05 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2006 |
|
| Chris Hart '08 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Taylor Jackson '06 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Taylor Palmer '07 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2007 |
|
| Warren Garceau '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Chris Hade '07 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Chris Hart '08 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Schuyler Horn '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Taylor Palmer '07 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Drew Schaffer '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2008 |
|
| Corey Best '11 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Peter Buongiorno '11 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Chris Hart '08 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Tim Horan '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2009 |
|
| Peter Buongiorno '11 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Tim Horan '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Drew Schaffer '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2010 |
|
| Corey Best '11 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Peter Buongiorno '11 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Connor Compton '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Sean Doherty '13 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Hudson Hackett '13 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Tim Horan '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Schuyler Horn '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Drew Schaffer '10 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2011 |
|
| Corey Best '11 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Ian Casey '13 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Patrick Crane '14 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Matt Guruge '14 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Cam Hanlon '14 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Billy McNamara '13 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2012 |
|
| Ian Casey '13 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Patrick Crane '14 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Sean Finn '15 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Matt Guruge '14 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| William Scott '14 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2013 |
|
| Ian Casey '13 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Patrick Crane '14 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Sean Finn '15 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| Billy McNamara '13 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
| William Scott '14 |
Pilgrim League All-Academic |
 |
|
| 2014 |
|
| Sean Finn '15 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
 |
|
| 2015 |
|
| Casey Buchholz '17 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Christopher Laudenbach '17 Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2016 |
|
| Casey Buccholz '17 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Zachary Brode '17 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| James Holston '18 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
 |
|
| 2017 |
|
| Casey Buchholz '17 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Zachary Brode '17 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Alexander Gafford '17 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| James Holston '18 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Christopher Laudenbach '17 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Matthew Morgan '19 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Liam Pearson '19 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
 |
|
| 2018 |
|
| James Holston '18 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference   |
| Matthew Morgan '19 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference   |
 |
|
| 2019 |
|
| Liam Pearson '19 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Matthew Morgan '19 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Neal Canastra '21 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Teg Cosgriff '21 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Tyler Brown-Ortiz '21 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
 |
|
| 2020 |
|
| Neal Canastra |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Thomas Cosgriff |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Brennan McIntyre |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
 |
|
| 2021 |
|
| Cory Bannon '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Daniel Benjamin '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Tyler Brown-Ortiz '21 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Neal Canastra '21 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Alexander Chu '22 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Thomas Cosgriff '21 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Samuel Kerrigan '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Dayton Kozlowski '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Brennan McIntyre '22 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| John Smyrski '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Nicholas Tarzanin '21 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
 |
|
| 2022 |
|
| Cory Bannon '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Daniel Benjamin '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Dayton Kozlowski '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Brennan McIntyre '22 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Jack Smyrski '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Jacon Wharton '24 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
 |
|
| 2023 |
|
| Daniel Benjamin '23 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Jack Smyrski '23 |
NEWMACÂ Academic All-Conference |
| Jack Board '25 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| John Drew '25 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Jacob Wharton '24 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
 |
|
| 2024 |
|
| Connor Almstrom '25 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Jack Board '25 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| John Drew '25 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Jacob Wharton '24 |
NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
 |
|
Totals:Â 100
Pilgrim League (51)
NEWMAC (49) |
|
